DUI Blog

RSS Grab Brooks and Crowley DUI Blog RSS Feeds


REGISTRY OF MOTOR VEHICLE CERTIFICATES CONSIDERED TESTIMONIAL, DOCUMENTS CONSIDERED INADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE WITHOUT LIVE TESTIMONY

Joseph Coupal - Tuesday, June 14, 2011
In order to convict someone of driving after suspension of license, the Commonwealth has to prove that the person received notice of the suspension.  Until last week, the government has been proving notice by offering into evidence a piece of paper from the Registry of Motor Vehicles, certifying that the attached notices had been mailed.  Courts have been admitting them as business records, even though the notices are typically created after the charges have already issued. However, last week in Commonwealth v. Parenteau, the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts held that a certification by the registry that a notice of suspension was mailed to the driver is a testimonial document, and not simply a business record.  Absent the appearance of a live witness to be cross-examined, such certificates, created after the fact, are inadmissible by themselves to prove notice of suspension.  The court held that to admit the certificates violated the defendant’s Sixth Amendment right of confrontation. This important decision will require someone from the Registry to appear and testify that a particular notice was mailed to the driver’s address, or at least that the practice of the Registry is to mail out notices to the address of record.  This requirement will surely add a level of difficulty to the Commonwealth’s ability to prove its cases.

[view google map]


Brooks & Crowley LLP serves clients throughout Massachusetts, and has offices in Dedham, Boston and Norwell


Main Office:

Brooks & Crowley LLP.
439 Washington Street,
Dedham, MA 02026
781-277-7321

Tel. 781-277-7321 | Fax 800-625-9021

Boston Office:

Brooks & Crowley LLP
112 Water Street
Boston, MA 02109

Tel. 781-277-7321 | Fax 800-625-9021

Norwell Office:

Brooks & Crowley LLP
320 Washington Street
Norwell, MA 02061

Tel. 781-277-7321 | Fax 800-625-9021

 

© Copyright 2019 Brooks and Crowley | All rights reserved. | Sitemap | Legal | Contact |

Web/Marketing created and maintained by WSI PRO Marketing.